בהמשך
לדיון שהתפתח פה, בנושא רישום הבעלות על מניות אצל ברוקר זר (כגון Interactive Brokers) אני ממשיך אותו כאן בשרשור הרלוונטי.
מעבר לדיון הנ"ל, הנושא דוסקס בעבר:
-
@daat99 ציין בשרשור הזה.
-
@doc29 ציין בשרשור נפרד,
כאן וגם
כאן.
פניתי ל-IB עצמאית, להלן ההתכתבות המלאה שלי איתם:
Support: Hello, this is 'Support'. How may I help you?
me: Hi
me: A question - When I buy a stock via IB, is it held using a Custodian or is the stock registered directly to my name?
Support: held in street name
Support: not directly registered
me: what do you mean by street name?
Support: held in the name of Interactive Brokers
me: So if I buy AAPL, as far as Apple is concerned, IB is the owner of the stock I bought and not me ?
Support: yes
me: What happens if IB shuts down?
Support: How We Handle Customer Assets
Customer money is segregated in special bank or custody accounts, which are designated for the exclusive benefit of customers of IB. This protection (the SEC term is "reserve" and the CFTC term is "segregation") is a core principle of securities and commodities brokerage. By properly segregating the customer's assets, if no money or stock is borrowed and no futures positions are held by the customer, then the customer's assets are available to be returned to the customer in the event of a default by or bankruptcy of the broker.
A portion of customer funds are typically invested in U.S. Treasury securities and FDIC-backed bonds. Although permitted by regulations, given the credit concerns over foreign sovereign debt IB does not currently invest any customer money in money market funds.
As a practice, IB holds an excess amount of its own money in these reserve and segregated accounts to ensure that there is more than enough cash to protect all customers.
Support: learn more about IB's strength and security policy here :
https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=2334&ns=T
Support: Although the securities are held in street name, they're for further benefit to the client's name
me: What does "for further benefit" mean?
Support: For further benefit means that it is ultimately for you
me: So while the stock is registered on IB's name, the custodian also has a note that I'm the final beneficiary ?
Support: yes
Support: we are the custodian
me: Buy what if IB losses track of the record that I'm the beneficiary?
Support: I can't answer hypotheticals , there are measures in place that prevent that from happening.
Support: we get audited and have regulatory policies to follow that ensure doesn't happen
me: OK. But just to make sure that I understand - IB tracks the fact that I'm the beneficiary and not that banks holding the securities?
Support: banks don't hold securities , we do . They're in book entry format
Support: we are self - clearing
me: So the banks (with 5% limit) only hold customers cash?
Support: what ultimately are you looking to confirm ?
Support: is a regulator asking you
me: no, I'm trying to understand for myself where is the final source of truth that has the record that a stock that I bought via IB belongs to me.
me: Is it only you, or is there an external record - say the exchange of SEC ?
me: * the Exchange or SEC
Support: one second
Support: your signed clearing agreement guarantees this. A copy is here :
https://gdcdyn.interactivebrokers.c...iew?doc=showConsolidatedClearingAgreement.jsp
me: This is a very long document, can you try and answer the question of - where is it recorded that the stock belongs to me?
Support: please read the agreemetn
me: Is it only in IB records, or is there a 3rd party that has the record
Support: 3rd party has a record of what ?
me: The fact that the stock belongs to me
Support: We are regulated by the SEC and CFTC
me: Does that mean that the SEC / CFTC have a record showing that I'm the owner of a stock I bought?
me: Ragini ?
Support: one moment
Support: The SEC / CFTC are regulators. The DTC - depository trust clearing keeps records of positions
Support: and as I said the DTC will see that the positions are with Interactive Brokers
me: DTC is the clearing house?
Support: yes
me: So when I buy a stock via IB, the clearing house (DTC) has a record that I'm the beneficiary of the stock, even though it's in IB's name?
me: If IB and all of it's records and backups go under, I will still be able to prove ownership via DTC?
Support: you would not prove ownership , If IB does bankrupt, Securities Investor Protection Corporation takes over.
Support: Customer securities accounts at Interactive Brokers LLC are protected by the Securities Investor Protection Corporation ("SIPC") for a maximum coverage of $500,000 (with a cash sublimit of $250,000) and under Interactive Brokers LLC's excess SIPC policy with certain underwriters at Lloyd's of London 1 for up to an additional $30 million (with a cash sublimit of $900,000) subject to an aggregate limit of $150 million. Futures and options on futures are not covered. As with all securities firms, this coverage provides protection against failure of a broker-dealer, not against loss of market value of securities.
For the purpose of determining an Interactive Brokers LLC customer account, accounts with like names and titles (e.g. John and Jane Smith and Jane and John Smith) are combined, but accounts with different titles are not (e.g. Individual/John Smith and IRA/John Smith).
SIPC is a non-profit, membership corporation funded by broker-dealers that are members of SIPC. For more information about SIPC and answers to frequently asked questions (such as how SIPC works, what is protected, how to file a claim, etc.), please refer to the following websites:
http://www.SIPC.org
http://www.finra.org/InvestorInformation/InvestorProtection/SIPCProtection/index.htm
or contact SIPC at:
Securities Investor Protection Corporation
805 15th Street, N.W. - Suite 800
Washington, D.C. 20005-2215
Telephone: (202) 371-8300
Facsimile: (202) 371-6728
me: If I have stocks values beyond the coverage limit, I will not get them back?
me: * stocks valued
Support: it depends it would be up to the creditors
Support: but you are guaranteed up to that amount , anything greater would be decided through SIPC , liquidators and bankruptcy court etc
me: Aren't the customer assets, especially the securities, separated from IB assets and be unavailable for any creditors?
Support: Customer-owned, fully-paid securities are protected in accounts at depositories and custodians that are specifically identified for the exclusive benefit of customers. IB reconciles positions in securities owned by customers daily to ensure that these securities have been received at the depositories and custodians.
me: in a segregated account
Support: only if you have fully paid for securities.
Support: You are in a margin account
me: Can you explain? I wasn't aware there is a difference. I'm in a margin account but I'm not using the margin. All the securities I own via IB are fully paid for.
Support: if you are in a margin account and fully pay for securities then you have are entitled to the full value of your account
me: by "entitled" - you mean that the securities are held in a segregated account in DTC and in case IB goes bankrupt the SIPC takes over and will grant me those securities, regardless of any creditor demands?
Support: more or less yes
me: That's good enough for now
me: Thank you for the patience
Support: no problem
Support: have a good day
ההתכתבות נמשכה כשעה ורבע, ולמרות שלא קיבלתי מענה מלא חתכתי. אחרי שהודתי לבחור ההודי שדיבר איתי על הסבלנות שלו הוא רשם את שני המשפטים האחרונים וסגר את הצ'אט במהירות הבזק שלא אספיק לשאול עוד שאלה
מסקנות:
- תודה ל
@חלכאי על שהעלה את הנושא.
- רציתי לשאול עוד כמה שאלות לגבי המכניקה והמשמעות של הרישום עם street name ו-"for further benefit" אבל לא יצא.
- אני די בטוח בהבנה שלי שהסיכוי לפגיעה במניות שלי הוא אפסי עד כדי לא קיים.
- לאור ההתכתבות, אני לא בטוח ב-100% אם אני נחשב הבעלים של המניה או לא. כלומר, אם באופן הרכישה הזה אני לא נחשב הבעלים של המניה על ידי "אפל" אז מתי כן?
- יצאתי מהשיחה קצת יותר מיודע ובעיקר יותר מבולבל.